Susie Grynol resigns from HAC, appointed VP at Marriott International
The Hotel Association of Canada (HAC) has announced the resignation of Susie Grynol from her position as president and CEO, effective June 3rd, 2024
The British Columbia Supreme Court in Canada has ruled that former employees terminated as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic can bring a class action against the hotel that employed them.
The British Columbia Supreme Court in Canada has ruled that former employees terminated as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic can bring a class action against the hotel that employed them, as reported by Lexology.
The British Columbia Supreme Court has certified a class action lawsuit brought by former employees against the owners of the Pan Pacific Hotel, located in Vancouver, B.C.
Background
Romeul Escobar, a former concierge with the Pan Pacific Hotel, was one of a number of employees of the Pan Pacific Hotel whose employment was terminated as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic.
With the support of a trade union, Unite Here, Local 40 (the ‘Union’), he filed a class action lawsuit in the British Columbia Supreme Court, seeking damages on behalf of a class of hourly employees of the hotel.
As filed, Escobar’s class action sought damages for claims arising from wrongful dismissal, the breach of the group termination provisions of s64 of the Employment Standards Act, the breach of the duty of good faith and honest performance, unjust enrichment arising from the group termination benefits Escobar claimed his employer should have paid and punitive damages.
As the class was comprised of hourly hotel employees, the claims for group termination pay and unjust enrichment were, in all likelihood, the ‘big ticket’ items identified by the Union in making the decision to pursue the class action. For many of the employees, their common law entitlement to damages for wrongful dismissal would be unlikely to be substantial.
The Supreme Court, relying on well-established legal precedence in British Columbia, concluded that rights granted by the Employment Standards Act are not enforceable in civil proceedings. As a result, any claim for group termination benefits, or claims for breach of the duty of good faith and honest performance arising from the group termination benefits, cannot form the basis of a civil claim.
The same rationale was applied to strike the claims relating to alleged unjust enrichment arising from the group termination pay which was not paid by the employer. Accordingly, those claims were also not certified by the Court.
With respect to damages for mental distress, as each employee would have a different reaction arising from the termination of their employment, the Court concluded it was not proper to certify that claim.
The Court then addressed the balance of the claims for damages sought in the class action. The Court accepted only the following common issues for certification:
The Court concluded that, in the face of these common issues, certification of the class action was appropriate. The claim will now proceed as a certified class action and marks one of the first class actions in Canada which deals with terminations arising from the COVID-19 pandemic to be certified. It is very unlikely that it will be the last.
Written by Paul D. McLean, Eric Kroshus, Mathews Dinsdale
The Hotel Association of Canada (HAC) has announced the resignation of Susie Grynol from her position as president and CEO, effective June 3rd, 2024
To commemorate International Women’s Day 2024, Choice Hotels Canada presents the remarkable journeys of four distinguished women leaders within the Canadian hotel sector. Their stories of resilience, innovation, and…
Atlific Hotels has appointed Christine Kennedy to chief executive officer.
Atlific Hotels has made new changes to its executive leadership, promoting Philippe Gadbois to chief operating officer and Mo Darehshiri to chief financial officer.